Minutes of a Parish Council Meeting
Held on Tuesday the 8th April 2025
Present: Councillors; Trevor Chalkley (Chair), John Barnsley, Simon Bennett, Rob Elson, Carol Gee, Bob Hewitt, Eric Robinson, Richard Tucknott, Sylvia Walker, Dwayne Walkington.
Apologies: Cllr Paul Blundell, Cllr Mark Gilbert, District Cllr Faith Heptinstall.
Clerk to the Council: Rebecca Maindonald
There were 4 members of the public present.
| 001/2526 | WMDC District Councillors Report. District Cllr Usman Ali thanked the Council for their support during the Crofton Day of action, which had been very successful. District Cllr Maureen Cummings passed on an email about footpath and it was hoped that the boundary would be re-instated soon. The pothole at Manor Fields’ s had been filled. The gully on Harrison Lane was cleared on the day of action, which was very successful. Traffic management was required to repair the banking on Shay Lane, due to the location, the work was on hold until it was arranged. It was thought that the poles had been installed by the school as the road is under their remit. The broken sign had been repaired. The gate by the bridge close to the Redbeck was to allow access for railway works. The traffic lights on bridge by Santingley lane- handed response over. Still unsafe and more work than originally thought. An issue had been reported concerning overhanging trees at Cundys Well, but work wouldn’t be undertaken as it was nesting time. It was noted that it was not an offence to block a drive if there was a dropped kerb. The meeting discussed- An issue concerning environmental health. Whether it would be possible in future to have a gang from Street scene concentrating on Crofton again for a day, similar to the Day of Action. The work on the cycle path near Hare Park. (Harron Homes) It had been part of the original plans for the development. The former caravan storage facility opposite the Sidings. Doncaster Road and the development of a farm building on farm land. The highways work in the Village, where both sides of the road were blocked. There had been no traffic lights or diversion. Springhill Grove still hadn’t been completed, 11 months later. The contractor had been out three weeks ago, went away to get a washer, and hadn’t returned. The contractor agreed that it was bad. Cllr Tucknott would contact Wakefield Council Customer Services Highways Department personally. The grass verge at Sidings- it had been suggested that no parking on the grass verge be allowed. It was noted that there had been a number of requests previously that had been refused, despite the issues parked cars caused with visibility. Cllr Bennett stated that he had written to the Highways Authority and there had been no response. The football club have spoken to people, but they still park on the verge. Cllr Bennett suggested a meeting with highways down at the Sidings as it needed to be assessed on a football day. The Spring Lane extension has been dismantled. |
| 002/2526 | Public participation, any person wishing to record the meeting in any format whatsoever is encouraged to contact the Clerk prior to the start of the meeting. No matters were raised. |
| 003/2526 | To receive apologies for absence and approve. Apologies received from Cllrs Mark Gilbert and Paul Blundell. |
| 004/2526 | Declarations of Personal and/or Pecuniary interest. None were declared. |
| 005/2526 | To consider the vacancy for Parish Councillor and any discuss any applications for co-option to the vacant seat. It was resolved to move this item up the agenda. There were two candidates for the position of Councillor. The Chair invited both candidates to speak. Candidate 1 confirmed that he was particularly interested in gardening and allotments. He worked in IT and felt that his skills would make him a useful addition to the Council. Candidate 2 confirmed that she had a strong background working with the community from a young age. She was experienced in applying for bids, and fund raising. She had experience in training, safeguarding and risk assessments. She was passionate about Crofton and would be moving into the Village soon. The Chair thanked both candidates for their interest and confirmed that a confidential vote would be held at the end of the meeting. The meeting noted that Councillor John Barnsley would be resigning as Parish Councillor, so a further vacancy would be arising shortly. |
| 006/2526 | Confirm and sign the minutes of the Parish Council meeting held Tuesday the 11th March 2025. Cllr Robinson stated that there was matter that he wished to query, but would do so once the Minutes had been approved by the Meeting. No further queries or observations were raised concerning the minutes. RESOLUTION- The Minutes of the meeting dated the 11th March 2025 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair. |
| 007/2526 | Confirm and sign the minutes of the extraordinary meeting held Tuesday the 25th March 2025. RESOLUTION- The Minutes of the extraordinary meeting dated the 25th March 2025 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair. Confirm and sign the minutes of the extraordinary meeting held Tuesday the 25th March 2025. RESOLUTION- The Minutes of the extraordinary meeting dated the 25th March 2025 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair. |
| 008/2526 | Matters arising from the previous minutes. Following extensive discussion, the meeting discussed whether to send a letter to John Trickett MP and Wakefield Council concerning the development at the Farm on Doncaster Road. Cllr Robinson questioned an item from the Minutes dated the 11th March 2025, which had been agreed and signed off. At the bottom of page 7 of the Minutes, there was the statement that the Reserves Policy had been agreed by the Clerk and Councillor Robinson. Councillor Bennett stated that he would not have stated that at the meeting, as he was aware that the Reserves Policy had been agreed and voted upon by the Council. Cllr Robinson confirmed that the reserves policy was adopted by the Council, following a vote, at the Parish Council meeting which was held on Tuesday the 7th January 2025. |
| 009/2526 a)
b)
c)
d)
| Planning. 25/00374/TPO- 6 Parkway, Crofton, WF4 1SX- T1 Beech: Crown Lift the tree to give 3.5metres of clearance from ground level and also crown reduce, clean and thin the tree canopy adjacent to the property of 4 Parkway and 19 Cock Lane to achieve 3 metres of clearance between the branch tips. The meeting discussed the application. RESOLVED to send a response requesting that work is undertaken only by a suitably qualified tree surgeon. 25/00552/TPO- 6 Ashdene Approach, Crofton, WF4 1LZ- Crown Reduce (T1) Lime from its current height (c. 20metres) to a final height of 10metres. (response required from WMDC) The meeting discussed the application. RESOLVED to send a response requested that the work was undertaken only by a suitably qualified tree surgeon. 25/00471/DEM- Weeland Road, Crofton, Wakefield, WF4 1LN- Demolition of existing buildings. The meeting discussed the application and agreed that no response was required. 25/00541/FUL- 2 Hall Park Avenue, Crofton, Wakefield, WF4 1LT- Single storey extension to rear. The meeting discussed the application and agreed that no response was required. |
| 010/2526 a)
b)
c)
d) | Finance/Accounts. To receive an update from the Finance working party. To discuss and agree any proposals and recommendations put forward by the Finance Working Party. Cllr Robinson confirmed that the Internal Controls checks had recently been carried out and the results had been circulated to the Parish Council. It was now the end of the Financial Year and all reports had reconciled. The VAT Claim for the previous six months had been submitted to HMRC and had been refunded. The Precept payment was due in mid-April. The Allotment income from Rent collection day had been paid into the bank account and there had been no need to call on any reserve funds. A paper had been received concerning the CVA Reserves, which had been prepared by Councillor Bennett. Cllr Robinson has requested that the Clerk provide a calculation of all reserves. To receive bank reconciliation and report on receipts, payments, balances. The Clerk ran through the bank reconciliation, receipts and payments for March. RESOLVED that the Schedule of receipts and payments for March 2025 be approved. To approve accounts for payment. RESOLVED that the accounts be approved for payment. To receive an update from the Clerk concerning the end of the Financial Year and the Audit process. The meeting received an update on the progress concerning the end of the financial year and the Audit process. She confirmed that all required files had been submitted to the Internal Auditor. The dates for public consultation were confirmed. The details would need to be posted on the website. The Clerk took the opportunity to thank Martin Walker for all of his assistance with the Website, particularly during the migration over to the Gov.uk domain. The Clerk ran through the end of year report, which had been produced using Scribe and asked whether the Council had any preference between that report and the historic spreadsheet. RESOLVED that the Clerk produce all financial reports using the Scribe accounting system in future and that spreadsheets should be abandoned. |
| 011/2526 | To receive an update from the SAFE scheme. The meeting noted the report, that had been circulated prior to the meeting. |
| 012/2526 | To receive an update on VE Day activities. The following arrangements were confirmed- The flag pole had arrived, the Chair would arrange for it to be installed by the millennium stone. Chair will arrange testing for cables at the site. The Silver band were unavailable. A music recording would be played. Cllr Walker providing details of a Veteran to do a speech. The Chair will do a speech. The Bench would be unveiled. Ration book picnic taking place at the Church. Resolved to Donate the sum of £100 to the Church for the Ration Book Picnic. Resolved to donate the sum of £50 to the organisers of the Cinema event for snacks and pop. |
| 013/2526 | Working Parties. Parish Centre. Cllr Bennett confirmed that the Architect would be providing sketches through for the Parish to view. Once provided, Cllr Bennett will scan them in and circulate it. CVA It was noted that the CVA had discussed the planning application at their recent meeting. They had also discussed a list of repairs that had been requested by users. It was agreed to compile a three-year plan of work. The Sidings would soon need a new three-year certification for electrics. Fees would be being reviewed at the next CVA meeting. The meeting discussed various matters concerning the Sidings. It was agreed that the CVA should remind all users of the facility that they should ensure that they remove muddy boots and shoes before entering the building, particularly if they had spikes, which damage the flooring. Allotments. Rent collection day had been reasonably successful. New tenancy agreements hadn’t been handed out. There had been quite a few complaints about the polytunnel. The Chair and Cllr Hewitt would go and assess it. Noted that people wanted it repaired or disposed of. Cllr Hewitt agreed to repair the tap. Floral Party A number of payments had been received. Constable and Pinders. There had been no recent expenditure. |
| 014/2526 | To receive items of Correspondence. None had been received. |
| 015/2526 | Parish Matters (Including Traffic Issues). Cllr Bennett confirmed that the library was going well. New members were joining and borrowing was consistent. The meeting discussed wildflower planting. Cllr Hewitt raised concerns about the cycle path and the safety of those using it. |
| 016/2526 | To discuss continuous code of conduct breaches. Cllr Eric Robinson recalled that there had been an informal meeting held in February 2025 which had been called by the Chair of the Council, where a number of issues concerning the treatment of the Chair and the Clerk were discussed. The outcome had been that a letter would be sent by the Chair to Cllr Bennett. To date, the letter had not been sent. Cllr Robinson confirmed that he had seen the contents of a letter the Chair had written, but not sent as the Chair had decided to have a one-to-one discussion with Cllr Bennett. Cllr Robinson reminded the Council that when a decision was made, it must be agreed, voted upon be voted on, then the decision of the Council should be supported by Councillors. Once it had been carried, the Council should get behind it. Individual Councillors should not repeatedly raise a matter if they had not supported it in the first place. Cllr Robinson went on to say that the second matter he wanted to raise was alarming. It was the continued breaches of the Council Code of conduct by Councillor Bennett. The Chair had discussed a number of emails that he had been sent by Councillor Bennett at the meeting in February. Cllr Robinson went on to say that Councillor Bennett had threatened to resign twelve months previously, if the Clerk was also appointed as Responsible Financial Officer. One of the emails that the Chair had read out at the February meeting contained a threat again, due to the January 2025 meeting carrying on, when Councillor Bennett had claimed it was unlawful. These threats continued, despite the Clerk and the Chair having obtained legal advice from a number of agencies the following day and having been assured that the January meeting was indeed lawful. Cllr Robinson felt that it was necessary that all of these issues should now be formally minuted. Informal meetings were not minuted so there were no official records of them every having taken place. Cllr Robinson felt that Cllr Bennetts behaviour toward the Clerk and Chair was intimidating and vexatious. Vexatious behaviour breached employment law. Cllr Robinson was concerned that this was affecting the Chair and it was certainly affecting the Clerk/RFO and Cllr Robinson wished that it would cease. Cllr Robinson requested that it be minuted that he did not condone this behaviour. He wants it to stop. Cllr Robinson stated that both the Chair and the Clerk were of good standing and should be supported and backed by the Council. The Clerk was excelling in training and development and Cllr Robinson felt that in her, the Council have someone who is trustworthy, approachable and a good person. Cllr Robinson stated that this treatment of both the Chair and the Clerk was not in his name. #notinmyname Cllr Robinson went on to say that he was concerned that if this behaviour didn’t stop, the Clerk would raise a Grievance. Whilst an individual would be named, the Grievance would be against all members of the Parish Council, as a corporate body. Any complaint made by the Clerk would need to be investigated externally, potentially by the Monitoring Officer at Wakefield Council and not by members of the Parish Council, as the complaint would be against the Parish Council. The Chair re-iterated that any complaint made by the Clerk would need to be dealt with in this way. The whole Council would be accountable for the actions of Councillor Bennett. Cllr Tucknott stated that the Council has a duty of care towards employees and also towards each other and this should stop. Cllr Hewitt thought that this behaviour had stopped. Cllr Walkington seconded everything that Cllr Robinson had said. Cllr Walker seconded everything that Cllr Robinson had said. Cllr Gee seconded everything that Cllr Robinson had said. Cllr Barnsley seconded everything that Cllr Robinson had said. Councillors agreed that they were concerned that they would be held accountable, in the event of the Clerk raising a grievance concerning her treatment. Cllr Robinson repeated that he just wanted the intimidation, harassment and vexing of both the Chair and the Clerk to stop. Councillor Bennett was a long-standing member of the Council and the Council would be worse off without him. Cllr Bennett stated that he had 30 years of experience on this Council. He refuted everything that had been said and that if he was the problem, he would be handing his resignation in. It was agreed that a line needed to be drawn and everyone needed to move on. |
| 017/2526 | To receive a report from the Chair of the Council, following the Clerk’s annual appraisal. The Chair confirmed that he and Cllr Robinson had undertaken the Clerks Annual Appraisal on the 4th April 2025. A copy of the report had been circulated to all Councillors. It had been a very positive process. The meeting acknowledged receipt of the Clerks annual appraisal, which had been caried out by the Chair and Cllr Robinson on the 4th April 2025. RESOLVED that the Clerks Salary be increased to SCP 30. Proposed by Cllr Tucknott, Seconded by Cllr Walker. |
| 018/2526 | Exclude the Press and Public. To resolve, in accordance with The Public Bodies (Admission to Meetings) Act 1960 Sec 1 (2), to exclude the press and members of the public from the meeting due to the confidential nature of the business to be transacted. |
| 019/2526 | To receive a staffing update concerning the position of Cleaner at the Sidings and decide therein. RESOLVED to offer the candidate the position as cleaner. |
| 020/2526 | To consider the vacancy for Parish Councillor and any discuss any applications for co-option to the vacant seat. On a Vote, Arron McNicholas was the successful candidate for Parish Councillor. The Clerk would contact him and advise him of the process. |
| 021/2526 | To agree date of the next Parish Council meeting – Tuesday the 13th May 2025 at 6.30pm. The meeting was closed at 21.30. |
Signed……………………………………………………………………………..………….Date………………..………….…
Chairman, Crofton Parish Council
